Checking on Your Fiduciary Liability Coverage
By: Victor H. Hicks II, CFP®, AIF®
Owner, Managing Principal
Lumin Financial, LLC
An Independent Registered Investment Adviser
Employers that sponsor 401(k) and other defined contribution retirement plans should review their fiduciary liability policies to make sure they provide adequate protection. Here’s some information you may find helpful when you check your coverage.
Fidelity Bonding Is Not Fiduciary Liability Insurance
Retirement plan fiduciaries face personal liability exposure that will not be protected by a fidelity bond. The pension law (ERISA) generally requires that every fiduciary of an employee benefit plan and any other person who handles plan money be covered by a fidelity bond. The fidelity bond protects the retirement plan against misappropriation of funds by individuals handling the plan’s assets. However, the fidelity bond does not protect against claims for losses sustained because of a breach of fiduciary duty.
Fiduciary Liability Insurance Protection
Fiduciary liability insurance provides protection for trustees and other plan fiduciaries in the event of a breach of fiduciary duty. These policies typically cover settlements or judgments. Wrongful acts that may be covered by fiduciary liability insurance include:
- Negligent investment practices
- Failure to diversify investments
- Failure to file required reports
- Conflicts of interest
- Errors in computing eligibility
- Inadequate instructions to beneficiaries that cause a loss of benefits
The benefit plan itself can purchase fiduciary liability insurance. However, the policy must allow the insurer to seek recourse against the fiduciary if it is determined that the fiduciary breached his or her duty to the plan. Commonly, the employer purchases the insurance as part of the overall compensation package of company executives who assume responsibility over the company’s benefit plan.
Check Coverage Carefully
Fiduciary liability insurance coverage varies widely from policy to policy, so it’s important to check what is covered in your policy and determine if you need additional coverage.
Occurrence or claims-made policies. Most policies are claims-made policies that only cover claims made and reported during the policy period. Look to obtain an occurrence-basis policy that covers all acts that occurred during the policy period, no matter when claims are made.
Aggregation of wrongful acts. If “wrongful act” is defined vaguely in a policy, insist upon a clear, objective definition. A wrongful act is generally defined as a breach of duty under ERISA, another federal law, or state law. And, if multiple wrongful acts may be treated as part of an interrelated series of wrongful acts, negotiate the elimination of this provision. Otherwise, this aggregation provision may allow the insurer to allocate a new claim as part of a prior claim, which may limit what is paid on the claim (in the event that the policy’s annual limit is unavailable to pay the claim).
Nonrecourse riders. If the policy is purchased with plan assets, the policy must allow the insurer to recover any paid losses from the fiduciary whose breach caused the loss. To protect themselves, individual fiduciaries can purchase nonrecourse riders. Under a nonrecourse rider, the insurer waives its subrogation rights against the fiduciaries in cases that do not involve fraud, willful neglect, or criminal wrongdoing.
Defense costs. To ensure adequate defense coverage, fiduciaries have the option to purchase a separate defense policy, since many policies count any costs of defending an action against the overall policy limit. Also, a policy may require you to accept defense counsel appointed by the insurer. Purchasing a separate defense policy will allow you to name your own defense counsel.
Punitive damages or fines. Since most policies will not pay punitive damages, you may want to negotiate coverage of punitive damages. Even if a policy covers the 20% penalty tax on fiduciary violations, it may not cover the 15% initial excise tax on prohibited transactions.
To learn more about fiduciary liability coverage, contact a Lumin Financial advisor.
Disclosure: Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any specific investment, or investment strategy. Investments involve risk and are not guaranteed. Information has been gathered from sources believed to be reliable, but cannot be represented as accurate or complete. Before investing, you should consult your investment, tax, or legal advisor.